How much are your cupcakes?

$3.75 each $19.50/half dozen $39/dozen

How do I care for my cupcakes?

Room temperature is best. Please remember refrigeration will dry out the cake. To preserve freshness, plastic wrap the bakery box or place the cupcakes in an airtight container.

How long do my cupcakes stay fresh?

Because Lilly Magilly's cupcakes are made with all natural (preservative free) ingredients, we encourage you to enjoy them at their freshest, on the day of purchase. If you plan to keep your cupcakes longer than two days, plastic wrap the bakery box or place the cupcakes in an airtight container.

Can I order in advance?

We encourage advance orders as it will ensure you get the cupcakes & cakes you want. We recommend at least 48 hours advance notice (please allow more time for holidays and large orders), custom cakes & cookies require 7 days notice, but if you forget to call in your order give us a call and check on our cupcakes, cookies & cakes availability. Pre-payment is required when placing advance orders.

If I order in advance, can I order any of your flavors?

Because we do offer a variety of flavors each day, we do require a 2 dozen minimum order if you wish to have a flavor that is not available on the day of your order.

Do you have mini cupcakes?

Yes, we do sell mini cupcakes. Mini-cupcakes are offered by advance order only. The cost is $18.00 per dozen with a 2 dozen minimum, 1 dozen per flavor. Note, not all flavors are available in Mini's, please call or email to inquire.

Does Lilly Magilly's Cupcake Shop deliver?

Delivery is available on some orders with advance notice!

Do you ship your cupcakes by mail?

Cupcakes are too delicate to ship so we are sorry shipping is not available. Cookies, cake pops & some sweet treats are available for shipping.

Can you do cupcakes for my wedding?

Yes! We love weddings and encourage you to come into the shop to purchase cupcakes to try at home. Delivery and set-up fees may be available for additional fees.

Can you do custom decorations?

Yes, please contact us for more information.

Do all of your cupcakes contain dairy/sugar/nuts?

We do bake with flour, dairy, eggs, sugar, pecans, peanuts, and walnuts on the premises, so Lilly Magilly's is not recommended for those with severe allergies to these ingredients.

Do you offer sugar free/gluten free cupcakes?

Not at this time.

Is there a Lilly?

You betcha!

facebook twitter Yelp!